Archive for April, 2007

A pointless feeler

Saturday, April 14th, 2007

Why announce this?

Israel is seriously considering participating in an Arab League working group to be set up as part of efforts to implement the decision taken at the League summit last month endorsing full normalization in return for a withdrawal to the Green Line, senior diplomatic sources said.

It would mark the first time Israel and an Arab League body have held diplomatic contacts, but the discussions would be limited to Arab League states that have ties with Israel: Egypt, Jordan and Qatar.

However, the sources cautioned that Israel had still not received any formal invitation to take part in working group discussions, and the Arab League had not yet set up the group. — Jerusalem Post

“Senior diplomatic sources” apparently didn’t explain how Israel could help ‘implement’ a plan that it is specifically not permitted to have input to: representatives of Saudi Arabia, Jordan, and Egypt have all explained that the plan must first be accepted in toto before there can be any talks. And as it stands it is a plan that Israel cannot possibly accept, since it includes a right of return for refugees, and a full return to the Green Line.

I understand that Israel needs to show that she is willing to talk, wants peace, etc. But the Arab league initiative is not an invitation to talk, it’s a take-it-or-leave-it package that Israel can’t afford to take.

Olmert has already suggested a summit between Israel and the Arabs on the principle that the Arab League initiative is a starting point for negotiations, not an end point. But the Arabs immediately rejected this.

Now Israel is inviting itself to a forum that doesn’t exist. The obvious next move is for the Arabs to announce that as soon as Israel accepts their initiative, they are ready to talk about practical details of the withdrawal and refugee return. Let’s see how long this takes.

Technorati Tags: ,

The US State Department has a plan

Friday, April 13th, 2007

Condoleeza Rice will be visiting the Mideast on a monthly basis, the US State Department says:

Israelis and Palestinians could start to explore fundamental peace issues this summer, US officials said, in a sign they believe some progress is possible despite myriad obstacles.

In interviews this week, senior US officials acknowledged the challenge of getting two politically weak leaders – Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert and Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas – to engage seriously on peace.

The problem is not in getting them to talk. The problem is in anything either of them says mattering.

(more…)

Guns before butter

Friday, April 13th, 2007

From the BBC:

Oxfam has called on the European Union to resume sending aid to the Palestinian government or risk its territories becoming a failed state.

Earth to Oxfam and the BBC:

  • It’s not a state.
  • Could things get any more ‘failed’?

Palestinian priorities never change: always guns before butter, killing Jews before feeding Arabs.

Technorati Tags: , ,

The Jews must not pay the price for the crimes of the Arab nations

Friday, April 13th, 2007

Arab MK Azmi Bishara has returned to Israel. In an interview to Israeli-Arab radio Al-Shams, he said:

We must remember that we are the original owners of this land. They want us to act like we are guests in our land, and always prove to them that we are ‘okay’. We are not ‘okay’. We are the Palestinian Arabs, sons of this land, and we will do whatever is right to resist occupation and aggression.

There really isn’t anything else to say about Bishara. I suppose someone could say “he is talking about the West Bank”, but I don’t believe that, and I bet that Bishara would agree with me if I could ask him.

What he is saying is that the State of Israel is illegitimate and the land of Israel belongs to the Arabs. That’s fine, it’s the same point of view held by Mahmoud Abbas, Ismail Haniyeh, Khaled Meshaal, Bashar al-Assad and many others. He is entitled to this point of view.

He is not entitled to hold it and be a member of the Knesset.

A Knesset member can hold very strong opinions about equal rights for Arabs and Jews and fair treatment for minorities in a democratic state. He cannot say that the state needs become an Arab state.

There was supposed to be a Palestinian state in historical Palestine; it became Jordan and is not ruled by Palestinians. This is not the Jews’ fault. Later (1947), there was supposed to be a Palestinian state alongside Israel and about the same size. It didn’t happen. This isn’t the Jews’ fault either. To turn a popular anti-Zionist argument around, Bishara shouldn’t expect the Jews to pay the price for the crimes of the Arab nations.

Technorati Tags: ,

More on not releasing prisoners

Thursday, April 12th, 2007

Marwan Barghouti (left) and Samir KuntarHa’aretz columnist Bradley Burston thinks that Israel should agree to release thousands of Palestinian prisoners (also see here), some of them mass murderers like Marwan and Abdullah Barghouti, in order to recover Gilad Shalit. He also thinks that Israel should be prepared to trade the monstrous Samir Kuntar for Eldad Regev and Ehud Goldwasser, held by Hizbullah.

(more…)